The Patriot Files Forums  

Go Back   The Patriot Files Forums > Military News > General

Post New Thread  Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 11-23-2019, 08:37 AM
Boats's Avatar
Boats Boats is offline
Senior Member
 

Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: Sauk Village, IL
Posts: 21,784
Arrow Science - Has A New Discovery Broken Known Physics?

Science - Has A New Discovery Broken Known Physics?
By: Don Lincoln - Science & Forbes - 11-23-19
RE: https://www.forbes.com/sites/drdonli.../#303bfdd565be

Science and the Internet have an uneasy relationship. Science is a community of sober and careful individuals who work very hard to release only solid results that have survived thorough and critical review. When that is done, the Internet can quickly disseminate the discovery quickly to a wide audience. On the other hand, the Internet frequently isn’t big on caution and nuance, and a story can spread widely before there is a scientific consensus.

Stories that report a discovery that extends or even breaks the current theoretical paradigm should be viewed extremely skeptically. A recent scientific paper claiming to have discovered a new particle that would mean a new and undiscovered force is one such paper. This doesn’t mean that the discovery is wrong – indeed a paradigm-changing discovery would look very similar – it’s just that we should remember Carl Sagan’s wise admonition that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. So, just what is this new scientific announcement?

A group of scientists working at a Hungarian Research Institute called Atomki claim to have found a new particle with a mass of 17 million electron volts (MeV). This particle, if confirmed, is about 33 times heavier than an electron and about two percent the mass of a proton.

They did this by studying a nuclear transition of a helium nucleus. In this transition, a gamma ray (e.g. photon) of 21 MeV of energy is released. At such high energies, the photon can convert into an electron and antimatter electron (positron) pair, and the angle between the paths of these two particles can be measured. Standard nuclear theory makes a clear prediction of the distribution of angles between these two particles.

When the researchers made this measurement, they found an unexpected excess of pairs of particles with an angle between their trajectories of 115º. This excess can be explained if an unknown particle with a mass of 17 MeV was made.

Such a discovery, if confirmed, would be grounds for celebration. Perhaps a new particle and a new force has been discovered. The story is made even more interesting because the same group made a similar announcement back in 2015 in a similar nuclear transition in beryllium, leading to an electron/positron pair and an excess of occurrences of trajectories with an opening angle of 140º. In the context of the beryllium measurement, the excess could also be explained as the creation of a heretofore undiscovered particle with a mass of 17 MeV, representing a new and unknown force. Thus, the recent measurement could be considered a confirmation of the earlier one. Furthermore, after the earlier discovery in beryllium transitions, a group of theoretical physicists devised a theory that was (a) consistent with all previous measurements and (b) predicted a new particle with a mass of 17 MeV.

So, does this mean that the champagne should be popped, and the Nobel Prize committee be notified? Well, no; not so fast.

While word of this discovery has spread across the Internet, the scientific community is not yet convinced and not convinced for several reasons. First the positive things. The first observation of this possible new particle created in beryllium transitions was submitted for peer review and the measurement was published in Physical Review Letters, a leading and highly respected physics journal. This means that the first measurement was evaluated by peer scientists and considered worthy of dissemination. Furthermore, the theoretical physicists who devised the explanatory theory are established and well regarded, and their theory was also published in the same journal This means that the theory has withstood at least cursory critical evaluation.

But the situation is not all positive. The two measurements, both the one involving helium and the other investigating beryllium, were performed by the same group. This is not truly independent confirmation. Furthermore, other experimental groups which should have been able to detect a particle with a mass of 17 MeV and the required properties have looked and found nothing. Thus, the particle cannot really be considered confirmed. Indeed, some would say that it has been refuted.

In addition, the theoretical framework proposed to explain the new discovery was very unusual. In the theory, the new particle would not interact with protons at all, what scientists call protophobic, and could only interact with neutrons, what scientist call neutrophillic. While this is not impossible, it is a very specific prediction, without anything comparable.

Finally, the more senior scientists who announced the supposed discovery of the 17 MeV particle have, over the last few decades, claimed the observation of a series of other particles, none of which have been confirmed by other groups. While previous examples of unconfirmed discoveries do not negate this one, this fact must give one pause.

So, what does this mean? Well, it is certainly possible that researchers have stumbled on something that no other group has found – after all, they are degreed scientists, with access to professional equipment. However, their history of unconfirmed announcements and lack of confirmation by other researchers suggests that extreme caution is in order. It would be hasty to consider the 17 MeV particle as established fact.

Debates like these – with scientists making claims and others trying to confirm or disprove them – are common in the scientific community. However, the advent of the easy communication of the Internet has allowed non-scientists to see the debate – how the sausage is made, so to speak. At the moment, the most prudent course of action is to wait for other groups to either confirm the announced discovery or to make additional measurements that prove it to be an example of an interesting bit of data that didn’t live up to its original billing.

About this writer: Don Lincoln is a senior scientist at Fermilab, America’s flagship particle physics laboratory, who has coauthored over 1,200 publications and was part of the discovery of both the top quark and the Higgs boson. I write extensively for the public on the topics of particle physics in cosmology, with several books, including “The Large Hadron Collider.” I also make videos on similar topics, both with The Great Courses Company and on the Fermilab YouTube channel. I have won awards from both the European Physical Society and the American Institute of Physics for my popular science writing, and I am a Fellow of both the American Physical Society and the American Association for the Advancement of Science.
__________________
Boats

O Almighty Lord God, who neither slumberest nor sleepest; Protect and assist, we beseech thee, all those who at home or abroad, by land, by sea, or in the air, are serving this country, that they, being armed with thy defence, may be preserved evermore in all perils; and being filled with wisdom and girded with strength, may do their duty to thy honour and glory; through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.

"IN GOD WE TRUST"
sendpm.gif Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links
  #2  
Old 11-26-2019, 01:01 PM
Boats's Avatar
Boats Boats is offline
Senior Member
 

Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: Sauk Village, IL
Posts: 21,784
Thumbs up A 'no-brainer Nobel Prize': Hungarian scientists may have found a fifth force of natu

A 'no-brainer Nobel Prize': Hungarian scientists may have found a fifth force of nature
By: Ryan Prior - CNN - 11-23-19
RE: https://us.cnn.com/2019/11/22/world/...rnd/index.html

2nd report on this subject: "Protophobic Force," (the 5th Force)

(CNN)Physics centers essentially on four forces that control our known, visible universe, governing everything from the production of heat in the sun to the way your laptop works. They are gravity, electromagnetism, the weak nuclear force, and the strong force.

Photo link: https://cdn.cnn.com/cnnnext/dam/asse...xlarge-169.jpg
Physicist Attila Krasznahorkay, right, works with a fellow researcher at the Institute for Nuclear Research at the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.

New research may be leading us closer to one more.

Scientists at the Institute for Nuclear Research at the Hungarian Academy of Sciences (Atomki) have posted findings showing what could be an example of that fifth force at work.

The scientists were closely watching how an excited helium atom emitted light as it decayed. The particles split at an unusual angle -- 115 degrees -- which couldn't be explained by known physics.

The study's lead scientist, Attila Krasznahorkay, told CNN that this was the second time his team had detected a new particle, which they call X17, because they calculated its mass at 17 megaelectronvolts.

"X17 could be a particle, which connects our visible world with the dark matter," he said in an email.

Jonathan Feng, a professor of physics and astronomy at the University of California at Irvine told CNN he's been following the Hungarian team's work for years, and believes its research is shaping up to be a game changer.

If these results can be replicated, "this would be a no-brainer Nobel Prize," he said.

Hungarian scientists are building on 2016 results

Three years ago, the Hungarian researchers published a similar paper in Physical Review Letters, one of the most prestigious journals in physics.

The nuclear physics experimental team had been studying another isotope, beryllium-8, as it decays down to a ground state. They saw electrons and positrons splitting off from the atom at unusual angles.

Those findings, which showed particles coming off beryllium-8 at around a 140-degree angle, were strange and new.

"We introduced such a new particle, which nobody saw before, and [whose] existence could not be understood by the widely accepted 'Standard Model' of particle physics, so it faced scrutiny," Krasznahorkay said in an email.

The findings by Krasznahorkay's team didn't get much attention at first, but they raised Feng's eyebrows. He said he "didn't want to leave potentially revolutionary results just sitting on the table."

Physicists in California developed a theory to explain the unusual results

In short, it could change physics as we know it, or it could have just been a simple lab error.

"Some people said they screwed up," Feng said.

But he believed the Hungarians were for real. His research group published a paper on the heels of the Hungarians' 2016 work, laying out a theory to observe what Krasznahorkay's experimental team had seen.

They referred to this unseen fifth force in action as a "protophobic force," meaning that it was as though the particles were "afraid of protons."

Meanwhile, nuclear physicists around the world set to work looking for errors in the Hungarians' work, and have come up empty-handed over the past few years.

"Some very well-known nuclear physicists have done that exercise," Feng said.

The numbers seemed to add up, and no one could find ways their equipment was calibrated incorrectly.

And Feng said his own team was comparing the Hungarian experiments "with every other experiment that's been done in the history of physics."

The only way to explain X17 was a hitherto undetected "fifth force."

The findings point toward the Holy Grail of physics

To move their breakthrough idea from 2016 forward, the Hungarians would need to repeat the results again. That's exactly what their 2019 results do.

Feng says that, barring experimental error, there was only a one-in-a-trillion chance that the results were caused by anything other than the X17 particle, and this new fifth force.

He added that if another research group could repeat these results with a third type of
atom in addition to beryllium and helium, "that would blow the cover off this thing."

Experimental research groups have already been contacting him, hungry to do that.

More sightings of the fifth force could lead to scientists settling on a specific name for it, understanding its workings more deeply, and developing practical applications for how to harness its power.

They're leading us closer to what's considered the Holy Grail in physics, which Albert Einstein had pursued but never achieved. Physicists hope to create a "unified field theory," which would coherently explain all cosmic forces from the formation of galaxies down to the quirks of quarks.

But the universe isn't giving up its secrets easily.

"There's no reason to stop at the fifth," Feng said. "There could be a sixth, seventh, and eighth force."

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Personal note: I've always been amazed in Einstein's work and calculations but this new 5th element X-17 particle - has got to be something really special. Not only that a 6th, 7th and 8th force may also be somewhere in the near future. If we are going to go into space we may as well have the science to understand it. It could be we can find time shifting back and forth through history. Fix it or destroy it could be the result(s). Folding space and getting to another galaxy in hours instead of 100k years would be something.

Boats
__________________
Boats

O Almighty Lord God, who neither slumberest nor sleepest; Protect and assist, we beseech thee, all those who at home or abroad, by land, by sea, or in the air, are serving this country, that they, being armed with thy defence, may be preserved evermore in all perils; and being filled with wisdom and girded with strength, may do their duty to thy honour and glory; through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.

"IN GOD WE TRUST"
sendpm.gif Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On

All times are GMT -7. The time now is 11:36 AM.


Powered by vBulletin, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.