Decrease Font Size Increase Font Size
Login

Military Photos



Current poll results


How do you feel about giving up freedoms for security?

It is a good idea6 %6 %6 % 6.19 % (7)
I do not mind8 %8 %8 % 8.85 % (10)
I might be persuaded3 %3 %3 % 3.54 % (4)
I have some concerns23 %23 %23 % 23.01 % (26)
It is a bad idea10 %10 %10 % 10.62 % (12)
I will never give up my freedoms47 %47 %47 % 47.79 % (54)
I have no opinion0 %0 %0 % 0.00 % (0)

Total votes: 113
One vote is allowed per day

[ Voting booth | Other polls ]

Comments

Display Order
Re: How do you feel about giving up freedoms for security?
by Anonymous
on Oct 30, 2001
If you have a safety issue, you deal with it. You do not give up your freedom to FEEL safe. If FEELING safe could MAKE you safe, we would never have accidents or disasters.

Casting off any part of your freedom to feel safe is like holding your breath to gain fresh air. Freedom is priceless. Once lost, it is difficult to recover.

Re: How do you feel about giving up freedoms for security?
by David
on Oct 30, 2001

We the people are the only ones who can ultimately secure our freedoms. We are the soldiers and sailors who stand in the breech during combat. We are the first and last line of defense from a foreign field to our doorsteps. The government is a guide and is meant to facilitate our will not direct us as they see fit. To allow our freedoms to be taken by any goverment, even our own, for any reason is truly a mistake.


Re: How do you feel about giving up freedoms for security?
by Anonymous
on Oct 30, 2001
Security is extrememly important to me at this point. Having lived through the WTC blast and the attendant recovery,I can tell you that New Yorkers feel much safer when they see armed cutters on the Hudson and armed national guardsmen at the airports. As I understand it, the recent extra powers given to law enforcement have a 4 year cap on them. That shows that law makers are thinking about this very issue.

What is freedom worth? What about the people who were shackled by the absence of certain constitutional rights during the Civil War. We recovered from that, didn't we? Don't get paranoid folks, freedom does you no good when your flattened by a sky scraper.


Re: How do you feel about giving up freedoms for security?
by Anonymous
on Oct 30, 2001
You said, "Don't get paranoid folks, freedom does you no good when your flattened by a sky scraper."

I would remind you that when your freedom is restricted, or gone with the wind, your security will be right on its heels. Don't be naive.

The Old Sarge


Re: How do you feel about giving up freedoms for security?
by Anonymous
on Oct 30, 2001
Ken,
I guess we have to agree to disagree. Though I am surprised. As a career military man I should think that you would have more faith in the Civilian/military relationship which ties directly into freedom vs. Security. I was only a 4 year vet. I am confident there will be/would be no problems. In fact on the way home from work tonight, I gave the thumbs up signal to an armed national guardsman guarding the approaches to the GW Bridge. I am not being naive. Its called faith in the nation.

Only logged in users are allowed to comment. register/log in
Military History
Forum Posts

Military Polls

Should Military Members be Allowed to Sue the Military?

[ Results | Polls ]

Votes: 481

This Day in History
1704: 50 French soldiers and 200 Indian allies attack Deerfield Massachusetts , killing 50 and taking 111 prisoners.

1836: General Edmund Gaines, and 1,100 soldiers have been engaged in a battle with a force of 1,500 Seminoles, under Chief Osceola, since February 27. The Americans built a stockade on the 27th. The Seminoles mount a major attack on the stockade. Many men are wounded on both sides during the attack. The fighting continues until March 6, 1836.

1856: Hostilities in Russo-Turkish war cease.

1864: Union Grig. Gen. Judson Kilpatrick splits his forces at the Rapidan River ordering Col. Ulric Dahlgren to lead 500 men his men to Goochland Court House, while the remainder followed Kilpatrick in his raid on Richmond.

1864: Lt. William B. Cushing leads a landing party from the USS Monticello to Smithville, NC, in an attempt to capture Confederate Brig. Gen. Louis Hebert, only to discover that Hebert and his men had already moved on Wilmington.

1940: 45 U boats are sunk this month (170,000 tons).

1944: US forces catch Japanese troops off-guard and easily take control of the Admiralty Islands in Papua New Guinea.

1952: Brigadier General Francis T. Dodd, the newly-appointed commandant for POW camp Koje-do, was warned that many of the compounds might be controlled by the violent leadership of Communists or anti-Communist groups. He was told this subversive control was extremely dangerous and could result in further embarrassment to the United Nations Command. Leaders were worried that rioting in the camps would undermine armistice negotiations.

1964: President Lyndon B. Johnson reveals the U.S. secretly developed the Lockheed A-11 jet fighter.

1972: South Korea pulls 11,000 troops out of Vietnam as part of its program to withdraw all of its 48,000 troops from the country.