Decrease Font Size Increase Font Size
Login

Military Photos



Current poll results


Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)

is pure BS.2 %2 %2 % 2.50 % (3)
justifies the mentally lame.0 %0 %0 % 0.83 % (1)
is a crutch to explain inappropriate reactions.0 %0 %0 % 0.83 % (1)
was invented by the VA to justify their existence.0 %0 %0 % 0.00 % (0)
can not be treated or cured.2 %2 %2 % 2.50 % (3)
is treatable but not curable.82 %82 %82 % 82.50 % (99)
is curable.6 %6 %6 % 6.67 % (8)
other, please explain in comments.4 %4 %4 % 4.17 % (5)

Total votes: 120
One vote is allowed per day

[ Voting booth | Other polls ]

Comments

Display Order
Re: Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
by Gimpy
on Jan 01, 2002
My main answer would be, that it is very treatable and very real. The vast majority fall into this catagory. However, except for the first catagories of B.S. and the VA using it for their benefit (and that might have some truth to it), each of the other opinions on PTSD have some true to it. So this isn't a black and white question. Generalization paints one into a corner.

Keith

Re: Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
by
on Jan 04, 2002
I agree with Keith. From what I've read, PTSD is about the same thing as Shell Shock, LMF and Battle Fatigue. I do believe that there is a good possibility that it has been overdiagnosed, just like most of the other syndromes du jour like ADD, etc. And, something I learned a long time ago..if you look at any psychiatric condition's symptoms, you will find that you have some of the symption (which does not mean you have the condition).
For example, I still have nightmares (always the same one), I have trouble sleeping, I carry around beaucoup anger (less than I used to)..but do I have PTSD? Can I justify it? My actual combat time was minimal..wasn't my job...tho being in a team consisting of 11 men & living on the economy certainly generated stress big time. So, in my case, I would say I have some symptoms but not full-blown PTSD.

Re: Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
by Anonymous
on Jan 04, 2002

When I was still living in Ohio, I was friends with two psychologists. They had patients from WWII that they were treating. Their opinion was that it was 50-50 for a successful cure. I do not have PTSD. I can talk about Vietnam and dream about without the problems some of other brothers in arms have suffered with.


Re: Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
by Anonymous
on Jan 06, 2002

The comments expressed here are similar to those in Australia. What we did find, based on US data was that the fighting in Vietnam was the trigger for two types of stress disorders. One was that which triggered an inherent personality defect which is immune to counseling or drugs. The other was a genuine stress disorder that was treatable through counseling and does emulate the characteristics of Shell Shock, battle fatigue etc. Nice to know we are on the same wave length.


Only logged in users are allowed to comment. register/log in
Military History
Forum Posts

Military Polls

Should the U.S. continue to reduce troop forces in non-combat zones overseas?

[ Results | Polls ]

Votes: 115

This Day in History
1787: Small farmers in Springfield, Massachusetts led by Daniel Shays, revolt against tax laws. Federal troops break up the protesters of what becomes known as Shays Rebellion.

1863: General Ambrose Burnside is removed as commander of the Army of the Potomac. General Joe Hooker took over command.

1919: The League of Nations, the forerunner of the United Nations, is formed in Paris, France. Lloyd George of Britain, Orlando of Italy, Clemenceau of France, and Woodrow Wilson of the United States are the original signers of the Leagues charter.

1943: The last German airfield in Stalingrad is captured by the Red Army.

1949: Axis Sally, who broadcasted Nazi propaganda to U.S. troops in Europe, stands trial in the United States for war crimes.

1951: General Ridgway and I and IX Corps launched Operation THUNDERBOLT, a counteroffensive northward to the Han River. This large-scale reconnaissance in force was the first ground offensive since the full-scale intervention of the Chinese. The purpose of the operation was to determine the enemys disposition of forces and reestablish contact.

1952: During the third largest aerial victory of the Korean War, F-86s shot down 10 MiG-15s and damaged three others without suffering any losses.

1953: Operation SMACK was launched in the western I Corps sector by the U.S. 7th Infantry Division. This air-ground coordinated test strike lasted three hours and involved close air support in concert with a combined arms task force of tanks, infantry and artillery. The operation achieved disappointing results.

1969: The first fully attended meeting of the formal Paris peace talks is held. Ambassador Henry Cabot Lodge, the chief negotiator for the United States, urged an immediate restoration of a genuine DMZ as the first "practical move toward peace."